Cannabis: Certain articles of the Quebec law invalidated by the Superior Court
Updated on
Cannabis: Certain articles of the Quebec law invalidated by the Superior Court
On September 3rd, 2019, the Superior Court of Quebec struck down sections 5 and 10 of the provincial cannabis law. Section 5 of the Act prohibited the possession of a cannabis plant while section 10 prohibited the cultivation of cannabis for personal use.
The Court considers that Quebec cannot modify the criminal law that is under federal jurisdiction to prohibit the production of the plant that is now legal in Canada. Quebec’s jurisdiction of healthcare cannot therefore be invoked to prohibit the production of cannabis for personal use.
The invalidation of the two Quebec articles ensures that the federal law will apply until the Québec government proposes new legal restrictions or challenges the decision of the Superior Court. The legal regime thus becomes that of Canadian law that allows the production of up to four (4) cannabis plants for the personal consumption of an adult.
Update: the Supreme Court settled the issue in 2023
This article reports on a September 2019 decision. It is no longer the state of the law. The Quebec Court of Appeal overturned that judgment in 2021, and the Supreme Court of Canada then confirmed, on April 14, 2023 in Murray-Hall v. Quebec (Attorney General) (2023 SCC 10), that Quebec’s prohibition on possessing and growing cannabis plants for personal purposes is constitutional.
What this means
- In Quebec, growing cannabis at home for personal use is prohibited, even though federal law allows up to four plants per residence elsewhere in Canada.
- The offence is created by provincial law and is punishable by a fine.
- The rules for medical cannabis are separate.
Need advice?
If you received a ticket or face a charge related to cannabis production, call us at 514 990-3430.
Votre Défense / Your Defence
229-3221, autoroute Laval O.
Laval (QC) H7P 5P2
514-990-3430
450-934-3414
www.VotreDefense.com
info@votredefense.com
Service hours
Monday – Friday : 9h00–17h00
Emergencies : 24/7