Impaired by alcohol or drugs: what to do
Updated on
Several amendments to the Criminal Code concerning driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs came into force in December 2018.
One of the most surprising provides that anyone who operates a conveyance (motor vehicle, vessel, aircraft or railway equipment) while their ability to operate it is impaired to any degree by alcohol or a drug commits a criminal offence if, within two (2) hours after ceasing to operate it, they have a blood alcohol concentration equal to or exceeding 80 mg of alcohol in 100 ml of blood (the well-known 0.08).
To be acquitted of this criminal offence, the accused must show the court all three (3) of the following conditions:
- They consumed the alcohol after ceasing to operate the conveyance.
- They had no reason to believe, when they ceased to operate the conveyance, that they would be required to provide a breath or blood sample.
- Their alcohol consumption is consistent with their blood alcohol concentration (established in accordance with the Criminal Code) and with a concentration below 80 mg of alcohol in 100 ml of blood (0.08).
Here are two concrete examples to help you understand this new provision:
EXAMPLE 1: It is about two in the morning and you are driving home from an evening with friends where a lot of alcohol was served. On the way back, you hit a parked vehicle and do not stop, thereby committing a hit and run.
A neighbour who saw the whole scene writes down your licence plate and calls 911 to report the accident. He gives a physical description of you and mentions that you are alone in the vehicle. By looking up your plate number in the CRPQ (Centre de renseignements policiers du Québec), the police easily find your address.
They knock at your door just as you have poured yourself a scotch on the rocks. They tell you that you are suspected of a hit and run, inform you of your rights and note obvious signs of intoxication (smell of alcohol, red and glassy eyes, slow and slurred speech, impaired coordination, etc.).
Under this new provision, they may arrest you for having driven your vehicle while impaired within the previous two hours and order you to provide a breath sample to measure your blood alcohol concentration with an approved instrument.
Your defence will most likely fail, because certain conditions will not be met:
- Yes, you are drinking alcohol after ceasing to drive when the police knock at your door.
- However, given the hit and run, you had a reason to believe that a breath sample could be demanded.
- The concentration measured by the approved instrument will be far higher than a single, barely started scotch on the rocks would explain.
EXAMPLE 2: It is about two in the morning and you are coming home from an evening spent babysitting your three nephews. They were into everything and kept you running all evening.
Nothing out of the ordinary happens on the road while you are driving.
As you line up with your driveway, you hit the snowbank on one side and need two attempts to park properly.
Your neighbour, who saw the whole scene, believes you were driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs and calls 911 to report the incident.
The police knock at your door just as you have finished a second scotch on the rocks, drunk in one gulp, to recover a little from your trying evening.
If, unfortunately, your explanations do not convince the officers and they see signs of intoxication where there are none (fatigue causes similar signs and your breath smells of alcohol), they may order you to follow them to the station to provide a breath sample with the approved instrument.
You will have a defence to raise:
- You only consumed alcohol after ceasing to drive your vehicle.
- You had no reason to believe, when you ceased to drive, that you might have to provide a breath sample. You only hit a snowbank in front of your home.
- Your blood alcohol concentration measured at the station will be consistent with what you actually drank (it is possible to establish a person’s concentration fairly precisely by calculating the time of the drinks, the millilitres of alcohol consumed, the alcohol percentage of the drink and the average rate at which alcohol is eliminated from the blood).
We are here to help you
Acting quickly when you face a criminal charge is essential.
Contact our criminal and penal lawyers for more information: 514 990-3430